I was wrong!‏

Dear brother Adib,

Here is the e-mail I had sent to you admitting that I was wrong.
Gulamhusein

"Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere"
                                                                                ...Martin Luther King                        
"Every gun that is fired, every warship launched, every rocket fired signifies a theft from those who hunger and are not fed, those who are cold and are not clothed".....Dwight Eisenhower

--- On Sat, 6/11/11, Gulamhusein Abba <gaabba2000@yahoo.com> wrote:

From: Gulamhusein Abba <gaabba2000@yahoo.com>
Subject: I was wrong!
To: "Adib S Karwar" <adibsk@cyberia.net.lb>
Date: Saturday, June 11, 2011, 1:49 PM

Dear brother Adib,   Ever since you raised your strong objection to my suggesti0n that Jews from all over the world be given a right to immigrate into the envisaged single-state Palestine, I have been thinking about it and have finally come to the conclusion that you are absolutely right. No such “right” is called for or justified. Agreeing to let the Jews who have poured into Palestine in their millions after the creation of Israel – agreeing to let them stay on as law abiding citizens of the single-state, secular and democratic Palestine to be formed is compassion and benevolence enough.   This will be in stark contrast to the so called civilized Western countries that looked the other way and refused entry into their ports to ship loads of Jewish refugees fleeing from the atrocities committed against them in Germany , Poland and other fascist countries. They were diverted to Palestine . And, by ultimately creating Palestine , these Western countries not only successfully kept away from their shores these Jews but laid the foundation for creating a long arm of their own in the Arab region.   By allowing the Jews that are already in Palestine to stay on, the Palestinians will be extending to them the compassion that the Western countries so cruelly refused to them in their hour of need. It is a heavy price the Palestinians will pay for cruelties against Jews not committed by them.                                                        ************ I am including here two items which you may want to tell your readers about. The first is about a video by a former Zionist, the son of a Jewish General no less. Your readers will be able to hear from the horse’s mouth as it were, the lies and misdeeds of the Zionists.   The second is a quote from Eisenhower. It is an excerpt from his address to the nation made on  February 20, 1957. Somebody should bring this to the attention of President Obama and the US Congress.   I have for long argued that there is no question of “negotiating” with Israel the terms of its withdrawal, much less as to how much of the land illegally seized by it is to be returned to its rightful owners, the Palestinians. What is required, I have consistently claimed, is enforcement (of international law regarding land acquired through force), not negotiations (see http://defyingsilence.blogspot.com/2010/07/time-to-muzzle-israel.html) . And now I have come across a quotation from no less than a former President of the US that fully supports my claim.   I am reproducing herewith, first the quotation from Eisenhower and then the item about the video.   The Eisenhower quote:   “Should a nation which attacks and occupies foreign territory in the face of UN disapproval be allowed to impose conditions on its own withdrawal? If we agree that armed attack can properly achieve the purpose of the assailant, then I fear we will have turned back the clock of international order …..”  Dwight Eisenhower.   The item about the video:     UNFORGETTABLE WORDS FROM AN ISRAELI GENERAL'S SON In the name of truth and justice PLEASE read the following and see the video Gulamhusein Abba UNFORGETTABLE WORDS FROM AN ISRAELI GENERAL’S SON They will shake you to the core.   “So those people who want to associate themselves with Israel, Zionism and drape themselves in the Zionist flag – the flag that has come to symbolize intolerance, hatred, racism and brutality – they can feel free to do so. But, they need to know this: that when the trials begin and the tribunals take their place, and when the truth and reconciliation commission begins its work and they are finally shamed into admitting they were wrong, they need to remember to go down on their knees and beg forgiveness from the people they so greatly wronged. They need to realize that we will never forget them and that their conscience will never allow them to forget that they supported the killings, that they draped themselves in the flag and that they mocked the bereaved. The rest of us will move on in line with the rest of the Middle East which will follow the example of the people of Egypt to create something that will surely be a tremendous accomplishment – a democratic, secular state in our own shared homeland – a state where Muslims, Christians and Jews live as equals and educate their children to love their homeland with its multitude of cultures, its rich history and its promising future.” SO ENDS MIKO PELED’S NARRATION YOU MUST WATCH THE WHOLE OF THIS POWERFUL VIDEO http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=c4ZfnpN4Dfc 28.25mins Please send on to family, friends, lists Spread as widely as possible The book “The General’s Son” will be available later this year.     PS: Blog: http://defyingsilence.blogspot.com/2011/05/unforgettable-words-from-israeli.html Video:http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=c4ZfnpN4Dfc 28.25mins "Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere" ...Martin Luther King                         "Every gun that is fired, every warship launched, every rocket fired signifies a theft from those who hunger and are not fed, those who are cold and are not clothed".....Dwight Eisenhower Mr. Gulamhusein Abba gaabba2000@yahoo.com Suggested that all the Jews in the world should be allowed to immigrate to Palestine, to which I replied to as per my comment in red below. Mr. Gulamhusein reconsidered his suggestion as he wrote: “admitting that I was wrong”. Adib

His claim of what  “everyone knows” and what “America and the international community can do” is just not true. He said that “a lasting peace will involve two states for two peoples: Israel as a Jewish state and the homeland for the Jewish people, and the state of Palestine as the homeland for the Palestinian people”. There are those who believe that a true and lasting peace will come about only if there is a single, secular, democratic state which recognizes the right of all people who now live there to continue living there, and the right of the Palestinian refugees to return to their ancestral lands as also the right of all Jews to immigrate to this single state to be known as Palestine, and guarantees all its citizens the right to vote and equal treatment. (The Jews around the world cannot immigrate to Palestine, they have no right to do so at all, they belong as the wise old lady, Helen Thomas, said they should return to where they came from, to their original homelands around the world…. But out of generosity Jews who invaded Palestine if they accept to remain in Palestine and as we said above, non Zionist Jews, and behave as good people they may stay. There is no place for 12 mil. Palestinians and 13 mil Jew in Palestine, Foreign Jews has no link or right to settle in Arab Palestine, they have ethnic or racial relation with Palestine they are converts to Judaism of central Asian roots; so what relation do they have with Arab Palestine!!!!

1.    My dear friend, it is a matter of principle that I disagree with having all Jews or any Jews of the world to invade (It is not a matter of immigrating, it is simply invasion, occupation and colonization of Palestine our own land). It is not our fault that they were maltreated or persecuted or even put to extinction (holocausted) to which in principle I disagree on, but I don’t give my country to them because they have nowhere to go to, anyhow they have their original homelands to stat or return to? Zionist want us Palestinian Arabs to go to Arab deserts to give them Arab Palestine. The British discriminated against Jews for religious reasons, so they created for them Zionism to look for a homeland of their own. They are British Jews so don’t discriminate against them so as for colonialist purposes have a homeland for them in Palestine to act as a long colonialist arm in our Arab homeland to exploit it. The west including America, England and France colonized the whole Arab homeland, and millions of Arabs lost their lives  and their wealth was stolen. The west headed by America and its western gangs invaded Iraq resulting in 1,500,000 martyrs, 4,700,000 displaced Iraqis, the country was dismantled and destroyed…. We Arabs suffered on the hands of the west and its Zionist Jews, the Zionist ex-minister of internal security wrote an article which he entitled “We destroyed Iraq” Israeli Internal Security Minister: We destroyed Iraq! The Oil of do you want more of them to replace us Arabs?, no sir, I don’t give the right to them even if they refuse to settle in Palestine. We have at least six million hate ridden of them… enough is enough, and we shall fight them forever till we liberate Palestine. There are Arab Jews for who we tell them you are our compatriots, and we don’t want you to leave your Arab homeland. Arab Jews were never mistreated as they were mistreated in the “civilized west”. We, out of generosity may accept some non Zionist Jews to stay in Palestine though they have no right on us to be obliged to. Netanyahu declared in the US congress, “Not a single Palestinian shall be allowed to return…” No to return to our occupied Palestine, so how dare we invite all the Jews of the world to “return to the so-called ‘Land of Ysrael’ I am an uprooted Palestinian whose land, home and fortunes were stolen by Zionists, do you expect me to be generous with them. You wrote about that. They want all Palestine to be a Jewish stae!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Adib